Cup of Coffee: November 19, 2026
Manfred speaks nonsense, Sonny Gray returns to Minnesota, a six-man trade between Seattle and KC, Frank Schloegel's annual guest post, Ryan Adams, and Jason Isbell + DBT
Good morning! And welcome to Free Thursday!
We've got a whole bunch of stuff today. Not bad for late November!
The Daily Briefing
We're officially in "who's gonna blink" territory in the labor talks

Yesterday Rob Manfred, who is in the middle of running the owners' meetings in New York, held a press conference in which he said that the owners were committed to rejecting any union proposal that does not contain a salary cap. Manfred:
"I will say there's plenty of room for compromise. But there's one thing I will not compromise, and that's the issue that we're hearing from the vast majority of our fans: They want salary cap and floor, and on that, we will not compromise."
Which is to say: Manfred thinks there is room to compromise but he will not compromise.
Manfred added this, when asked a question which noted that the union said a salary cap was a "non-starter":
"Another word for 'nonstarter' over months is a refusal to bargain. I think it's time that the MLBPA needs to realize that this proposal is serious. I'm not suggesting they need to accept it whole cloth. I think they need to look at the proposal and try to find some ways to move to the middle as opposed to making no proposal at all."
I know that there are several baseball reporters with credentials to the owners meetings who read this newsletter. I would love it if one of you were to ask Manfred how the players are supposed to, to use his words, "move to the middle" when the only thing in dispute is a purely binary thing: salary cap or no salary cap. I genuinely want to hear his answer to that question.
MLBPA Executive Director Bruce Meyer responded in a statement:
"There can be no clearer example of the league's lack of seriousness than their insistence that they will not negotiate over the economics outside of a radical change to the system that would dramatically reduce overall player compensation for all categories of players and strip fundamental rights from players like the ability to have truly guaranteed contracts. There should be no illusions about the owners' true motivation in pushing for this system. They want to make more money in profits and franchise values by artificially suppressing player salaries."
Manfred said that he and the owners have not yet decided to impose a lockout, claiming that if it happens it'll be a last minute decision made only if necessary, but if you believe that you're crazy. He said that so, later, if this all winds up in litigation, that he can claim he and the owners were negotiating earnestly when they're clearly not. Manfred will, without question, impose a lockout the second the clock strikes midnight on the night of December 1, and he's already started planning for it.
Manfred is committed to the bit, though, and said that he's still willing to talk:
"We're going to devote ourselves to the bargaining process. I'm not that big on Thanksgiving as a holiday. We'll make ourselves available whenever and wherever to bargain in an effort to make an agreement."
That's the super relatable human person we've all come to love.
You all know that I'm constitutionally in the bag for labor, but I don't think that it takes an MLBPA mark like me to appreciate that when one side stands willing to discuss any and all terms that have been a part of labor contracts for up to half a century, and the other side will accept absolutely nothing short of radical, wholesale change to the very basis of labor's relationship with management, that it's not the former party who is unreasonably refusing to compromise.
Whatever the case, we're where we knew we'd eventually end up: either the players will have to abandon their unwavering, decades-old opposition to salary caps or the owners will have to abandon their push for a cap which they tried and disastrously failed to impose 32 years ago and just revived again just recently.
Which is to say, I have a feeling how this is going to go. Whether we get there before too much baseball is lost strikes me as being totally up to the owners.
Sonny Gray signs with the Twins
Free agent starting pitcher Sonny Gray has signed a two-year deal with the Minnesota Twins worth $55 million. There is an opt-out after the first year.
Gray, 37, tied for the major league lead with 18 wins in his lone season in Boston, posting a career-best 2.72 ERA (150 ERA+) and striking out 149 batters across 169 innings. He had a mutual option worth $30 million for 2027, a term that he and the Cardinals had agreed to before he signed with them three years ago, but it had a $10 million buyout so Gray declining his end of that was an easy choice. He has now cashed in twice in the space of a month.
This is not Gray's first stint with Minnesota, of course. He pitched there in 2022 and 2023, finishing second in AL Cy Young voting in the latter season. When he signed with St. Louis he was leaving a Twins team that had won 87 games and made the postseason in 2023. His leaving was occasioned by the Twins slashing payroll and spending the next three years on the outside looking in. Since then, the Twins owners tried to sell the team and then decided not to sell, Tom Pohlad ousted his younger brother Joe as the team’s control person, and they took on new minority owners who provided an influx of cash to pay off outstanding debts.
The Twins committing money to Gray now – and some more modest acquisitions in the past several months – at least suggests that they're prepared to increase the payroll and to attempt to seriously contend in a division that eminently winnable even for the Twins. And with Gray, Joe Ryan, Taj Bradley and, eventually, Pablo López, who is recovering from elbow surgery, they'll have a pretty darn good rotation to help them do it.
Mariners and Royals complete a six-man trade
The Seattle Mariners and Kansas City Royals swung a six-man trade yesterday. The deal:
- Mariners get: Third baseman Maikel Garcia, right-hander James McArthur and minor league righty reliever L.P. Langevin;
- Royals get: Right-hander Bryce Miller, righty Logan Evans and lefty José A. Ferrer.
Garcia, 26, hit .268/.334/.381 (102 OPS+) with three home runs and five steals while playing just 82 games this season due to multiple injuries. In a healthy 2025, however, he hit 16 home runs and stole 23 bases while getting an All-Star nod and wining the Gold Glove. He just finished the first year of a five-year, $57.5 million contract extension he signed with Kansas City in 2025 that includes a club option for 2031.
The big piece coming back to the Royals is Miller, who posted a 2.94 ERA (126 ERA+) in 180.1 innings in 2024 but has been battling elbow injuries the last two seasons, leading to a combined 8-16 record and a 4.82 ERA (80 ERA+) over 209 innings for 2025-26. Given two bumpy years Kansas City is gambling on a return-to-form and the old change-of-scenery bounce. Miller is arbitration-eligible for 2027 following the Royals' declining his $6 million+ club option for 2027 last month. He'll likely make north of $3 million in arbitration.
As for the other players included in the deal for the Mariners, McArthur once closed for the Royals but he didn’t pitch at all in 2025 and missed almost all of 2026. Langevin, 23, just completed his second go-around in High-A. He strikes out everyone and walks everyone. You know the type.
As for the subsidiary pieces going to Kansas City: Evans had a promising debut in 2025 but had internal brace surgery on his elbow in January and missed the entire 2026 season. He might be a rotation option for the Royals at some point in 2027 but he still has some ramping back up to do. Ferrer throws hard and induces ground balls. He was unlucky on balls in play in 2026 but should serve as an able late-inning option for the Royals.
My overall assessment: the Mariners filled an infield need, got the best player in the deal who is under team control for a long time, and only parted with question marks, not core arms. The Royals got a lottery ticket starter – but more like a scratcher, not a Mega Millions – a useful reliever, and they're saving a few million bucks.
I like this deal for Seattle than I like it for Kansas City.
Red Sox acquire a catcher from the Rays
The Boston Red Sox did more than watch Sonny Gray walk yesterday: they acquired catcher Nick Fortes in a deal with the Tampa Bay Rays in exchange for minor league righty Angel Roa.
Fortes hit 258/.304/.376 (89 OPS+) with six home runs and 35 RBI in 109 games for the Rays in 2026, but he's a defense first catcher who will serve as Adley Rutschman's backup in 2027. They then DFA'd Connor Wong to make room. Wong, by the way, was the last guy on the team who came over in the Mookie Betts trade, so I guess we must grudgingly, and at long last, admit that the Dodgers won that deal.
Roa is a 17-year-old right-hander who pitched 22.1 innings in the Dominican Summer League so, for our purposes, he's just a guy.
Tiger-Angels make a minor trade
The Angels acquired infielder Jace Jung from the Detroit Tigers for cash considerations. Which is about the most Angels move ever.
Jung used to be a prospect, so he's a name a lot of us probably recognize, but he hasn't produced in a few short big league stints and seems stalled out at Triple-A. If the Angels were one of those franchises known for unlocking potential from guys it'd be different but they're not that.
A-Rod being A-Rod
Alex Rodriguez spoke to the New York Times about MLB's labor battle. At one point he noted that, yes, he was a union member for nearly 25 years and understood the players' rejection of a salary cap. But he also spoke as the part-owner of the Minnesota Timberwolves and in that role he appears to have fully embraced the ethos of sports ownership:
“If you’re owner, what you’re fighting for is — you have some envy here,” Rodriguez said. “You have the four major sports in America: hockey, football, baseball and basketball. If you look at the last number of years, NFL and NBA have gone up about 20 percent a year, year-over-year compound. NHL has been a surprise 27 percent. And then you have baseball under single digits, like under 4 or 5 percent. So, they’re looking at the other leagues and saying, ‘I want what they have.’ Makes sense. You want to return capital, you want to make money for your partners and you want to make it fun, but also you don’t want it to be a bloodbath”
His comments were cast as "seeing both sides of it" but apart from that acknowledgement of players being against salary caps, he seems to be pretty OK with a salary cap, as long as you don't call it that:
So how does Rodriguez think it will end? He’s got some thoughts on that, too. His first suggestion is to avoid the words “salary cap.” But his suggestion sure seemed like a ceiling of some sort and a raised floor, though he said, “I’m always going to support the players because I’m part of the union.”
“It’s not a math problem; I think it’s an English problem,” he said. “I think you have to go in there and say, look, the world’s changed from 1994. We’re no longer number one. We are doing great things. We need to keep building on this moment, and we’re going to find a way to make all of you more money collectively. Yeah, at the very top, if you’re (Juan) Soto, you may not make $850 million. You may make $750 (million). But we’re taking the guys that may play three or four years, and we’re going to elevate the floor.”
To sum up: when Alex Rodriguez was the highest-paid player in baseball, salary caps were worth fighting against, but now that he's of the ownership class the highest-paid player in baseball makes too much and there should be a mechanism of capping salaries though we should not call it a "cap."
People called A-Rod "self-centered" and "greedy" when he signed that $250 million deal with the Rangers back in the day. But signing that deal didn't make him greedy – he was more than worth it – and, as you'll recall, he willingly changed positions in order to win, which cuts against him being self-centered. But becoming a sports owners sure as hell made him those things.
Other Stuff
Guest Post: Frank Schloegel

Heidi's husband Brian carried their baby, Frieda, up the path at Bear Mountain State Park in the Palisades Region of New York. My wife and I drove up with them to go to the Octoberfest party. We got some food and beer and rode the carousel. And then we hiked up the path to the tower at the top of the mountain.
Lovely views all around. The foliage was exceptional that year.
It was getting late in the afternoon, and, following a day of eating and drinking and hiking, I found myself in need of a restroom that was not a tree in the woods. Being late, the restroom in the tower that I was planning to use was locked.
My hiking companions were all at peace and enjoying the view. They unpacked the baby and were feeding her. Sensing that there was absolutely no urgency to return to our van at the bottom of the mountain. I suggested that I would hitch a ride down and come pick everyone up.
The group was confused by this, but I left them no alternative and set off to get to a bathroom as fast as I possibly could. I did not feel this was information that the group needed, so without much of a plan and very limited cell service (in what must have been 2003) I ran off and flagged down a car.
I have hitchhiked across Colorado and though this may seem a bit insane to a novice, if you flag down a car with only men, a bit older, and ask for a ride they will say “yes.” So I jumped into the back seat of a 4-door sedan. The front seats occupied by older men with gray hair, the back seat occupied by an empty vodka bottle rolling around. It became clear immediately that these were two eastern European gentlemen well into their cups heading home, who spoke very limited English.
I did not exactly understand the layout of the roads. We had hiked up the “front” of the mountain, and I was driving down the back. It felt like at the bottom we would need to go left to get to the parking lot. But who could be sure? I thought we had reached an agreement to get me to the parking lot. But there was a language barrier.
We went right at the bottom. I was holding out hope. Then we came to a clearing, and there was a highway, and we got on it. “Whoa! Whoa!” I yelled, “Where are we going?”
The driver turned and looked at me and said with a heavy Russian accent, “Staten Island.”
“No! Stop! Thank you!” I jumped out on the side of what was likely the Palisades Parkway. It’s one of those weird east coast highways without trucks that thinks it is a quaint boulevard, but everyone is driving 100 miles an hour. So I Froggered across the thing. I was about a mile from the exit at this point, which is far generally, but in my current state was an impossible distance.
I was going to try to hitchhike, but this was not the place for that. And I only needed a ride one mile before I would need another ride. Panicked and frantic, I was speed walking (not too fast) while half heartedly looking for a ride, when what miracle should appear but a yellow cab! I hailed a yellow cab on the side of the Palisades Parkway!
The cab pulls over I run to it and jump in and slam the door behind me. At this point I realize there is a 20 year old white girl already in the back seat. She is wearing cat ears. There is also a young woman in the front passenger seat. Also wearing cat ears. The driver is an older African man, who says with a heavy accent, “Hello.”
I am thinking, what in the name of Pulp Fiction did I just get into. And I say, “I need a ride to Bear Mountain.” And he says, “We are not going there.” So I say, “Ok.” And I go to get out of the cab and the door is locked. And I think, “I am going to shit my pants and get murdered.”
And the man smiles, and unlocks the door. And I run off towards the exit ramp.
Eventually I end up in my van, and I am driving up to pick up my future wife, my brother in law, my niece and my sister Heidi.
They were walking down the mountain toward the parking lot when I found them. They got in and, though a bit confused about my absence, they were mostly happy to be done walking. Of my passengers, my sister Heidi was most interested in what had occurred. Where had I been all this time? Her interest, unfortunately, was piqued.
I didn’t really want to tell the story to begin with, and then in the telling it became apparent how absurd it all was. It took a very long time just to explain the Russians. (I call them the Russians, but they were more likely Polish, but it’s the east coast and they could have been from any number of countries.)
Also I was driving. So I couldn’t really orate, “Sing in me, Muse, and tell the story of that man skilled in all ways of contending.” I bet Homer was not pestered with questions about details. All the way back to the Bronx, the story circled around.
“I don’t know why the cab stopped!”
“Yes! They were going to drive me all the way to Staten Island!”
“I don’t know!”
We finally made it back to the Bronx and went to get food and drinks at An Beal Bocht – a great spot that I assume is still going strong. We found a cozy table and a nice pint. And they forced me to continue the story.
After the cab, I flagged down a nice couple in a Subaru and they gave me a ride to my car. I probably told them more of the insane tale they wanted to hear, and I am sure they were relieved when I got out of their car without incident. Then I got in the van and came to pick you up.
But Heidi was not convinced. Something was not adding up. Why? Why had I run off? Why get in the car with the drunk Russians in the first place? Why did you get in a cab without looking? Why!
Fine! Fine?! You want the truth!?
“After I got out of the cab I was running toward the exit ramp and I had to run off the side of the road and take a crap in the bushes. I had to use my undershirt as toilet paper and it’s still there and I feel bad about littering. Happy?!”
I can report that, yes, they were happy. My dear sister Heidi was able to laugh about that day for the rest of her life.
My sister died of cancer in November of 2019. She created a lot of good in the world and improved the lives of people in her community. We had a lot of memorable times together. I would appreciate it if you could make a donation to Heidi’s Healthy Canasta, which is a program of The Mary Mitchell Family and Youth Center in the Bronx. Or if you are in Kansas City, you can drop off some food at 415 W Dartmouth Rd, KCMO 64113 on Tuesday November 25, 2026, which we will deliver to Harvesters. Text or message me to let me know when you will stop by and I will be sure to be there (646-342-7344).
Dan Carney: 1931-2026
Dan Carney who, along with his younger brother Frank, founded Pizza Hut in 1958, has died at the age of 95.
This is a supreme loss. It sure as heck ain't makin' it great for his friends and family. May he rest in Priazzo. Er, I mean peace.
Oh my god, whatever, etc.
In her song "Motion Sickness," Phoebe Bridgers wrote about her ex Ryan Adams and his habit of preying on and attempting to control young women just starting out in his industry, singing pointedly, "you were in a band when I was born." Now Adams is going after women who weren't born for more than four years after that band broke up. From Entertainment Weekly:
Ryan Adams is getting married.
The Grammy-nominated singer-songwriter announced his engagement to fellow musician Kate Farr on Tuesday . . . Adams, 52, told the outlet that his proposal to Farr, 22, came after a whirlwind six-month romance. The two were introduced by mutual friends earlier this year.
Of course she's 22. He was probably interested because he couldn't get a date with anyone who was old enough to read back when the exposé about him being a manipulative, controlling abuser of women came out. Congrats on playing the long game, Ryan. Everyone who knows anything believes you're evil, but no one ever said you were dumb.
Isbell + DBT
There's this cliche out there about middle aged baseball writers being super into Jason Isbell. As someone who has been singing his praises since Twitter began taking off, I'm probably one of the reasons that cliche exists. I am now living up to the cliche, as yesterday I purchased tickets to see Isbell's just-announced tour with his old band, Drive-By Truckers next August.
There are lots of dates – yesterday and today are the pre-sales; general sales go down tomorrow – but none in Columbus. Normally my next move would be Detroit, Chicago, Cleveland, or Cincinnati, in that order of preference. Except the Detroit and Chicago shows conflict with a different thing I'm doing, there is no Cleveland show, and the Cincinnati show is (a) close enough to that different thing that, while I could make it, I really don't wanna rush around like that; and (b) it's an outside show in August in Cincinnati which is invariably a nightmare due to storms, stifling humidity, or both. Also: I hate driving to Cincinnati more than almost everything for a bunch of reasons that have more to do with me and my psyche than it has to do with the actual logistics of the drive. It's a long story probably better told to my therapist than all of you.
So I'm going to see them in Durham, North Carolina on August 20. We get down there a couple of times a year due to having friends in the area, we like it quite a bit, it's a cheap, quick, direct flight to RDU from CMH, we have status with the hotel that is literally attached to the venue, and that venue is indoors. Check, check, check, check. Tickets purchased and hotel room booked on a flexible reservation in case my life spins out of control between now and then or events otherwise overtake me.
I love going to Isbell shows. It's sorta like how your dog feels when he goes to the dog park and sees all of his buddies. Except its a bunch of liberal 5o year-old white guys doing the butt-sniffing.
Have a great day everyone.
Comments ()